I'm sorry in advance about running on tonight but there was just too much I wanted to say about this issue. Twice within the last three days there were posts on my Facebook news feed from two different mothers asking the same question: "My twelve-year-old daughter wants to get a belly button ring. What does everyone on here think?" Each one got a multitude of responses, some people saying it was fine but most saying the girls were too young.
Let me ask you this. When do our kids stop being 'too young' to make decisions for themselves?
Now, some of you are probably saying "Sixteen is a good age; kids become more responsible by then and are capable of making more mature decisions." Then others of you are probably saying, "When they're 18 and legally adults. Until then they are incapable of making any rational decisions without my input." Or even better, "When they move out of my house. Until then, it's my house so they follow my rules."
Those are all good theories or beliefs or whatever you want to call them; unfortunately, I have to disagree. I believe that kids need to be able to make a few decisions for themselves that we may not really like so they can learn from the consequences whether negative or positive. We all went through it with our own parents and I know I hated my mother always telling me what I could and couldn't do because she felt she knew what was best for me even though we disagreed on things I consider simple today.
For instance, I'm betting that you all allow your kids to pick out their own clothing in the morning, don't you? Of course we try to teach our kids to dress respectfully but if your kid walks out of the house wearing an orange shirt with purple shorts and green socks are you pulling him back in the house and forcing him to change his clothing? Probably not. My sister did that and though our mother didn't pull her back in the house she definitely made my sister feel bad about it.
You might also allow your kids to wear their hair they way they want, I'm sure. Whether your son wants to wear a Mohawk or your daughter wants to tip her braids in bright blue I'm guessing you're not exactly pleased with it but you don't stop them because it's their hair. You probably also don't control everything they eat or in what after-school activities they can participate. I'll bet you also allow them to make lots of other decisions for themselves without stepping in to correct them.
Yes, there are certain issues where we put our foot down solidly followed by a "Nope, not in my house." Daughters are not allowed to dress provocatively or wear too much make-up, sons are not allowed to sag their pants, and we don't allow them do spend their time participating in harmful activities. Those are the types of things that we teach our kids so they learn respect for themselves, respect for others, and to keep them from getting hurt. I have no problem with that.
I do have a problem, however, with the reasoning that children are always 'too young' for something they want. They're too young to have a sleepover at a friend's house, they're too young go to the mall with friends, they're too young for something as simple as a piercing. "A PIERCING IS NOT SIMPLE, ESPECIALLY A BELLY BUTTON PIERCING!! SHE'S TOO YOUNG!! THOSE ARE FOR GIRLS WHO WANT TO ATTRACT GUYS!!!" Really? I know of no 12-year-old girls who are so interested in boys that they feel they have to get their belly button pierced to attract one.
How many of you let your sons get one or both of their ears pierced before they were 12 years old? How many of you let your daughters polish their nails when they were five or wear even a little bit of make-up when they started Middle School? It's no different when you really think about it. A piercing is not permanent, the girls are not asking for tattoos. They're asking for a small adornment that you've probably already allowed them to have on their ears. It's also something that the girls may get rid of as they get older.
My now-11-year-old son, Zach, asked to get his ears pierced when he was five. He'd asked when he was four and, like you, I thought he was too young. When he asked again the next year, and kept asking, I thought about it and came up with two realizations for myself. 1) The earrings weren't permanent and they are his ears, not mine and 2) He needed to feel he had some control over his own body at some point in life. Why was I making him wait? I allowed him to get his ears pierced. He hardly ever wears them now.
Zach's older brother, Ty, hasn't wanted to cut his hair for about three years. Up until school ended last year his hair was just below shoulder length, long compared to all the boys he knows. Rex (their dad, my ex-husband) hated Ty's hair. "He needs to get a haircut!" My answer to him was almost the same as it was when he complained about Zach's earrings, "Sorry, it's his hair and he can wear it how he wants. Nobody tells you how to wear your hair." He didn't like it but he shut up about it.
When this past summer began Ty asked me to cut his hair a little shorter, so we did. It's now about four inches shorter than it was but still on the long side. Ty likes it, Rex still hates it, I don't care either way. It's not my decision to make, it's Ty's.
I've always tried to give my kids some freedom with their choices because I'd rather they learn to make reasonable and safe choices now, and learn from any mistakes, than have them make unreasonable and unsafe choices when they're older. The way I see it, if I try to control too much now, as soon as they're 'old enough' they'll run around making all kinds of choices that I disapprove of and that may not be all that safe simply because they can whether they've thought them through or not.
I've seen it happen with friends I grew up with and with the children of friends I have now. Mom or dad put their foot down way too much when the kids were young and as soon as they weren't looking and the kids were 'old enough' the kids were out causing and getting into trouble, so much so that it ruined their lives. No joke.
These days I see pre-teens walking around with their own cell phones - don't say it's for safety, I didn't have a cell phone when I was a kid because there weren't cell phones and I always knew how to call home if I needed to. I also see pre-teens with their own social network pages - Facebook, Twitter, Instagram and all the rest. Parents will allow their children the freedom to use technology where they can interact with friends as well as strangers yet Mom and Dad won't allow a piercing where the only one who's affected is the kid getting pierced. It's amazing to me.
I'm not saying that we have to give in to everything our kids want but we do need to put some thought into it rather than simply saying no all the time just because we think our kid is too young. Constantly saying no creates resentment and rebellion in the kids and there's always a battle of the wills between parent and child. If we give in on a few things now, things that aren't harmful to anyone involved, our kids will be more likely to come to us to get our opinions on big decisions later in life. I don't know how you feel about that but it's certainly something I'd like.
Until next time... peace to all.